The Toronto Maple Leafs are in New Jersey to play the Devils tonight. The standings suggest this game may not decide the playoffs, but with 21 games left, both teams are running out of time to define what kind of season this will be. Toronto is nine points out of the final wild-card spot. The Devils sit two points behind them.
Related: Today in Hockey History: March 4
New Jersey is coming off a strong 5–1 win over the Florida Panthers, one of their better all-around efforts this season. They’ve been inconsistent, but lately they’ve shown some life. Toronto, on the other hand, is 3-8-2 in its last 13 and hasn’t won since the Olympic break. Monday’s shootout loss to the Philadelphia Flyers was better, but moral victories won’t move them up the standings.
Goaltending matters, especially with back-to-back games – the Maple Leafs face the New York Rangers on Thursday. Joseph Woll shut out the Devils in December and could get the nod again. Jake Allen is the likely starter for New Jersey. Special teams could swing the game — and with both teams still chasing their seasons, every edge counts.
Item One: Time to Think Out of the Box with the Hunter Brothers?
Thinking about how the Maple Leafs finish out the season, there are likely to be meaningful changes. So, why not do more than tweak around the edges? In my research for today’s News & Rumours, I read Howard Berger’s blog Between the Posts. While we sometimes disagree, his thinking is valuable. He mentioned Easton Cowan’s mentors from last season, the Hunter brothers.
Related: Kris Knoblauch Should Be the Maple Leafs’ Next Head Coach
Mark and Dale Hunter have built the London Knights into a machine. They’ve won Memorial Cups and, season after season, are in contention. They draft well and develop good players by demanding accountability and focusing on both culture and skills. They don’t hype, but they have a track record that spans decades.
Both have had NHL opportunities. Dale coached the Washington Capitals briefly before returning to London. Mark was right in the mix for the Maple Leafs’ GM job in 2018 before Brendan Shanahan chose Kyle Dubas instead. He moved on, and the team chose its path.
But here the Maple Leafs are again, nearly 60 years without a championship. You have to wonder whether the organization needs a different type of leadership. The Hunters have always emphasized structure, standards, and internal competition. That kind of culture shift might be uncomfortable. It’s also a bit old-school and new-school at the same time. Could such an out-of-the-box move work in Toronto? It would sure be a different road to travel.
Item Two: The Strange Case for No Coaching Change
What fans rarely see are the conversations taking place inside the organization when a season starts to drift. At some point, the discussion stops being about bad bounces and starts being about responsibility. Was this year undone by injuries and inconsistency? Or is the issue more structural — systems, preparation, messaging?
Related: NHL Rumours: Oilers Not Done, Maple Leafs Changes, Matthews and Tkachuk
If management believes this roster is capable — that the core is good enough to compete — then the focus naturally shifts behind the bench. In that scenario, a coaching change becomes the cleaner solution than moving significant pieces of the lineup. You adjust the voice before you dismantle the talent. That’s logical.
But timing complicates the picture. The 2026 first-round pick sent to the Boston Bruins for Brandon Carlo last March is top-five protected. While it remains unlikely Toronto falls into that territory, it isn’t impossible. And that sliver of possibility matters. Midseason coaching changes often create a short-term surge. Teams respond emotionally. The danger is climbing just high enough to miss the playoffs while also sliding out of range to retain a premium draft asset. That’s the NHL’s version of no-man’s land — improvement without reward.
So the real question isn’t whether the coach deserves criticism. It’s whether acting now serves the bigger picture. Draft capital and long-term flexibility carry weight in the salary cap era. If the organization still believes in its core, patience may be more strategic than a reaction meant to send a message.
Item Three: The Danger of the Middle Ground
This is where the season becomes less about frustration and more about direction. The worst place in the modern NHL isn’t necessarily the bottom of the standings. The bottom offers clarity. It offers a draft position. It offers a defined path forward. The most uncomfortable place is the middle, where this team is not good enough to contend, not bad enough to reset.
Right now, the Maple Leafs are flirting with that middle ground. Too far back to feel secure in a playoff push, yet talented enough to beat good teams on any given night. Every decision from here carries real weight. Do you chase a long-shot run and risk future assets? Do you sell and send a signal? Or do you evaluate behind the scenes and prepare for structural change in the offseason?
Related: Maple Leafs News & Rumours: Woll, Nylander, Babcock & Berube’s Job
This may ultimately be less about the current head coach, Craig Berube, and more about organizational self-awareness. Is this roster underperforming? Or has it plateaued? Is the issue tactical? Cultural? Competitive? Those answers can’t be rushed in March.
What’s Next for the Maple Leafs?
Tonight’s game against the Devils matters, but the larger issue is clarity. If the Maple Leafs understand what they are — and what they aren’t — the path forward becomes easier to choose. With the trade deadline approaching, the focus shifts beyond one result.
Management must decide what this season represents. Is it a long shot still worth chasing? Or is it a transition year that demands patience and discipline? The standings will sort themselves out soon enough. The more important decision is philosophical. And that choice — not one game in New Jersey — is what will shape far more than the final month of this season.
