For years, Mitch Marner was one of the most polarizing figures in Toronto Maple Leafs history—praised for his playmaking brilliance, but criticized for not delivering enough when it mattered most. Made the scapegoat for so many things that went wrong for the organization in games that mattered, his play this season — and for another team — has the same fans who bashed him looking back and wondering if they might have been a bit harsh.
The narrative that Marner was to blame for the Maple Leafs playoff failures is starting to look a lot more like an excuse for Leafs Nation, many of whom needed a place to point fingers. The reality is that Marner wasn’t the problem, and he’s proving it as part of the Vegas Golden Knights.
Marner Is Reminding Fans He’s Pretty Darn Good
Marner’s playoff run with Vegas is forcing a difficult re-evaluation in Toronto. While the Leafs are looking at a long summer of change — including new management trying to get the team back into the playoff mix — Marner’s natural hat trick this weekend—his first in the postseason—was more than a painful reminder. It was a statement.
Marner showed everyone that he can take over a game and, in the process, score goals.
In Toronto, Marner’s production was steady, even impressive at times, but it rarely felt dominant. He was harped on for only putting up assists, a situation that somehow led fans to suggest he wasn’t a superstar. Instead, Marner wasn’t clutch, they argued. He was overpaid and overhyped, argued others.
Sure, the goals didn’t come in bunches. And yes, the Maple Leafs couldn’t “get it done” with him as part of the Core Four. Still, one look at how bad the Maple Leafs were this season and how much success Marner has found in Vegas shows that any validity to the argument that he’s not a game-changer is being torn apart in real time.
The Marner Playoff Narrative is a Bunch of B.S.
Golden Knights head coach John Tortorella didn’t hesitate to stand up for Marner when asked about the baggage he brought over with him from the Maple Leafs. He called the long-standing narrative “a bunch of bulls**t,” and noted that people don’t see the way Marner impacts a game, even if he isn’t always scoring.
“You guys don’t see the stuff he does. People here, people in Toronto. They don’t see any of the things he brings to game, even if he doesn’t score a goal,” said Tortorella. Perhaps the most ringing endorsement of Marner came when Torts said Marner doesn’t care. “He’s a hockey player,” said the coach, suggesting that the narrative, as loud as fans and analysts want to make it, doesn’t affect how Marner plays.
Of course, context matters. The pressure in Toronto is unlike anywhere else in hockey, and Marner is likely thriving in an environment where every move isn’t overanalyzed. The Golden Knights are a solid and deep team, and if they succeed, he’s not the hero. If they fail, he’s not the reason. At least not in the Vegas market. It remains that the Maple Leafs’ media and fans are the only ones with opinions. It’s ironic given that what Marner does or doesn’t do should no longer matter.
Instead, the question lingers: was the problem ever really the player—or everything around him? Because no matter how disappointing this season has been, and the focus should be on getting better, Leafs fans can’t help but watch as Marner rewrites his story somewhere else.
Free Newsletter
Get Toronto Maple Leafs coverage delivered to your inbox
In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes – free.
Subscribe Free →
