You know, right now, the talk around the Toronto Maple Leafs is pretty grim. Everyone’s saying the same thing: a long rebuild ahead, years of pain, maybe even a total teardown. And I get it — it was a lost season without playoffs. In addition, looking back at losing players like Fraser Minten, Bobby McMann, and a bunch of other promising youngsters under Brad Treliving’s watch really stings.
Related: Maple Leafs News & Rumours: Stecher, Cowan, Hundley, Buhr & Muzzin
The Maple Leafs have been making the playoffs regularly, even if they didn’t go far. About the trades, from the organization’s current reflective position, those were the kinds of youngsters who were supposed to grow into the next wave. When you ship out that kind of young talent, and the results don’t follow, it’s easy to feel like the franchise is sliding into a deep hole with no quick way out.
An Optimistic Look at the Maple Leafs Predicament
I tend to err on the side of optimism, and this might be the latest example. But here’s the thing I keep coming back to, and I know this is an optimistic view of the situation. Is there a chance that fans and hockey writers are too dire in their predictions?
(James Guillory-Imagn Images)
What if everyone’s underestimating the Maple Leafs roster, and the season was more bad luck and bad management than weakness? Maybe the Maple Leafs don’t need a massive, multi-year overhaul to start winning again — they could turn things around much sooner than people expect.
One Reason the Maple Leafs Might Turn It Around Quickly
The biggest reason the Maple Leafs could turn this on a dime is their solid goaltending. They did last season, and if Joseph Woll and Anthony Stolarz both return to form, a strong season isn’t out of the realm of possibility. Obviously, their defence can’t be a sieve again. But if they can stop the pressure, the goalies could come through.
Related: Simplistic Thinking Won’t Fix the Maple Leafs — Here’s What Might
They also need to get some shots on the opposition’s net. Right now, Toronto isn’t generating nearly enough sustained pressure in the offensive zone. They’re not flooding the other team’s end with shots or forcing defenders to chase the puck the way their best teams did. That could simply be a coaching thing, because this season’s Maple Leafs have been outshot in almost every game I can remember.
Always Playing in Your Own Defensive End Puts Too Much Pressure on the Goalies
Constantly defending your own zone puts an awful lot of extra work on the goalies. But here’s the hope: they already have two good, solid netminders. If those goalies can get back to the form they showed last season — calm, confident, stealing games when they need to — and if the team in front of them starts playing a little smarter in its own end and spends more time attacking, the whole picture changes fast.
Think about it. A stronger defensive structure in front of the net means fewer odd-man rushes and fewer high-danger chances against. More time in the offensive zone means more shots, more tired opposing defencemen, and more opportunities for the skilled forwards they still have.
Related: Maple Leafs Being Questioned Over ‘Sketchy’ Search Firm Hiring
It’s not rocket science — it’s hockey 101. When your goalies aren’t seeing rubber all night long, they can actually steal you some wins instead of just trying to survive.
And, If the Injured Players Come Back Strong
And that’s where the bounce-back players come in. If Auston Matthews gets healthy and returns to anything close to his old self, if Matias Maccelli stays and finds his playmaking touch, and if guys like Dakota Joshua bring back that gritty, forechecking energy they showed in past seasons, the Maple Leafs suddenly look a lot more dangerous.
(David Kirouac-Imagn Images)
They don’t need a total roster makeover. They need the pieces they already have to play the way we know they can.
Look at what happened in Buffalo with the Sabres this season. They changed the general manager, made a few smart tweaks, and suddenly the team started climbing out of its own long funk more quickly than anyone predicted. It wasn’t magic — it was better structure, better buy-in, and a little bit of health. Toronto could follow a similar path.
Obviously, There’s No Guarantee of a Bounceback
Now, I’m not saying any of this optimism is guaranteed. Nothing in this league ever is. But the team could certainly bounce back.
But the Maple Leafs have more talent in the room than most rebuilding teams ever dream of. If they tighten things up defensively, spend more time in the other team’s end, and let their goalies be the difference-makers they were last season, this “long crawl out of the hole” could turn into a much shorter walk than anyone expects.
Related: 9 Cool Things About Dave Semenko: Edmonton Oilers’ Enforcer
The coldest time of the night is just before the sun starts to peek through. This is as down a season as any of the nine in which I’ve covered the Maple Leafs. But I’ve also seen enough seasons to know it doesn’t always take forever to turn things around. Look at the Boston Bruins.
Sometimes it just takes making some smart moves, believing the guys you already have can do the job, and a bit of puck luck. Hockey can be a funny game that way.
